European LVNAV Money Market Fund Sector Outlook Goes Negative

Published 

London/New York – Fitch Ratings has revised its sector outlook for European low volatility net asset value (LVNAV) money market funds (MMFs) to negative from stable, driven by price volatility affecting fund mark-to-market (MTM) net asset values (NAVs) and heightened outflows. Fitch believes that risks for the sector have increased due to investor risk aversion, unprecedented market volatility, and the increased potential for credit deterioration of underlying issuers.

LVNAV MMF ratings could be downgraded if these trends are sustained, and if material redemptions result in structurally impaired liquidity positions. The secondary market is challenged, which increases the importance of natural liquidity (near-term maturities) in the funds, and the stability and profile of their investor bases. The suspension of redemptions by a fund would lead to a downgrade to ‘BBmmf’ or below, in line with Fitch’s rating definitions.

European LVNAV MMF flows were volatile in the week to 20 March 2020, with material outflows causing some funds to sell securities to meet redemptions and reducing their liquidity buffers above regulatory minimums. Fitch-rated funds have mostly weathered outflows to date, meeting redemptions using natural liquidity and selling of securities. A limited number of funds have experienced minor or temporary breaches of Fitch’s ‘AAAmmf’ weekly liquidity rating range. Accordingly Fitch is monitoring these funds more closely to understand the extent to which they will be able to remedy the breaches in a timely manner.

Outflows were highest in USD-denominated funds (USD46.9 billion or 15%, according to iMoneyNet data). This followed the trend in the US, where investors redeemed from onshore US prime MMFs in favour of onshore government MMFs. Euro and sterling-denominated LVNAV MMFs saw outflows of GBP16.6 billion (8%) and EUR15.2 billion (15%) respectively. Following these events, euro, sterling and US dollar-denominated LVNAV MMFs averaged 33%, 34% and 36% weekly liquidity, respectively, according to iMoneyNet calculations. This was above Fitch’s minimum weekly liquidity threshold at the ‘AAAmmf’ rating level, though with limited buffers.

European and US MMF liquidity regulations differ. In the US, a breach below 30% weekly liquidity is enough to force the fund’s board to consider imposing a liquidity fee or redemption gate. In Europe, both a breach of 30% weekly liquidity and a simultaneous net outflow above 10% on the same day are needed to force the board to consider such action, although a liquidity breach alone, or even a near-breach, may accelerate outflows as investors rush to beat possible fees or gates. The imposition of fees or gates, however, is always entirely at the board’s discretion in both the US and Europe.

If an LVNAV MMF’s MTM NAV were to deviate from a stable value (1.0000) by more than 20bp, it would temporarily switch to variable pricing. (If the MTM NAV moves back within 20bp of the stable value, stable pricing would resume.) Investor reaction to a switch is hard to gauge as such a scenario has never occurred. The largest deviation between stable and MTM NAV in Fitch-rated LVNAV MMFs was 15bp at 20 March. Funds with longer weighted-average lives or higher outflows have been most affected. A breach of the NAV corridor would not, in itself, trigger a negative rating action but a downgrade would be likely if variable pricing led to outflows that resulted in severely reduced liquidity or gating of the fund.

Fitch believes that the lack of policy measures to support MMFs in Europe poses additional risks relative to US MMFs. The Bank of England’s and ECB’s recent liquidity provisions for commercial paper apply to non-financial commercial paper only, and so cannot be used by MMFs. In contrast, the US Federal Reserve’s money market mutual fund liquidity facility includes financial commercial paper. Moreover, European MMF regulation bars funds from receiving support, in contrast to several recent cases in the US where affiliated entities purchased securities from MMFs.

One mitigating factor for European MMFs is that the relative attraction of government MMFs in Europe is lower than in the US. European government MMFs have gates and fees, whereas US government MMFs do not. While breaches of liquidity thresholds in European government MMFs are unlikely, given their eligible asset characteristics, the imposition of fees or gates is not impossible.

Most recent episodes

Advantage Treasury

Eleanor Hill is joined in the virtual TreasuryCast studio by Nicolas Cailly and Philippe Penichou (Societe Generale) to look at treasury trend predictions for the remainder of 2022, with a particular focus on virtual accounts. In this deep dive into current and future treasury priorities, our guests consider...

24:22

40th Annual New York Cash Exchange: What Can Treasurers Expect?

Ahead of the 40th annual New York Cash Exchange, two of TMANY’s distinguished board members, David Miller and Timothy T. Hesler, CTP, provide TMI CEO, Robin Page, with a quickfire rundown of what attendees can expect from this year’s conference. Our guests share their aspirations for the event,...

09:58

Expectation-Beating Inflation Prints Ratchet Up Pressure on Monetary Policy

Welcome to the third edition of Liquidity Link Live, your exclusive market analysis provided by Northern Trust Asset Management, one of the world’s largest cash managers. Tune in each month to discover the very latest insights on the UK, Eurozone and US markets. This edition was recorded on the 9th May...

04:48

Making the Sustainable Transition: A Roadmap to ESG in Treasury

Over the last 18 months, Societe Generale has experienced a steady increase in requests from their corporate clients to integrate ESG features in treasury management.  Louis-David Rouyer, Philippe Pougeard, and Emmanuelle Petelle (Societe Generale) provide TMI’s Eleanor Hill with a whistlestop run...

22:24

Lift Off for Fed Rate Rises

Welcome to the latest edition of Liquidity Link Live, your exclusive market analysis provided by Northern Trust Asset Management, one of the world’s largest cash managers. Tune in each month to discover the very latest insights on the UK, Eurozone and US markets. This edition was recorded on the 5th of...

04:58

Treasury in 2022 and Beyond

Industry experts Bob Stark (Kyriba) and Sebastian di Paola (PwC) join TMI’s Editor, Eleanor Hill, to explore the very latest treasury trends – and to discuss how smart treasurers can get ahead of the game by ...

43:21

How BearingPoint Harnessed Data-Driven Forecasting with CashAnalytics and SAP

Listen back to our recent forecasting masterclass, where Group Treasurer Eveline Stam, and Conor Deegan (CashAnalytics) provided TMI’s Eleanor Hill with a comprehensive overview of how consultancy firm BearingPoint achieved company-wide cash forecasting nirvana by combining specialist solutions from...

37:14

The 3 T’s of The Future: Tech, Treasury, and Transformation

Over the past two years, an increasingly dynamic environment has not only accelerated technology development – from quantum computing to blockchain technology, and even the metaverse – but also technology adoption, bridging colleagues and breaking down silos in a remote work world. In this podcast,...

44:02

Monetary Policy Continues to Drive Markets as Ukraine Invasion Weighs on March Meetings

Welcome to the second edition of Liquidity Link Live, your exclusive market analysis provided by Northern Trust Asset Management, one of the world’s largest cash managers. Tune in each month to discover the very latest insights on the UK, Eurozone and US markets. This edition was recorded on the 3rd of...

05:25

Tax Spotlight: How the OECD’s Two-Pillar Solution Impacts Treasury

Aaron Lee and Joseph Lee (DBS Bank) join TMI’s Eleanor Hill to discuss how the OECD’s Two-Pillar Solution aims to address the tax challenges arising from the digitalisation of the economy. Ahead of the 2023 implementation date multinational corporates will have much to consider around these reforms....

24:00