Fitch: Governance of European money funds to face greater investor scrutiny

Published 


London
: The governance of European money market funds (MMFs) will be under greater investor focus as a result of forthcoming reforms, given the prominence of liquidity fees and redemption gates in the new regulation, says Fitch Ratings in a new report.

The reforms became effective for new funds on 21 July and will apply to existing funds from January next year. They assign the ‘board’ additional responsibility for reform-specified fee and gate tests, on top of the existing discretion over applying a wide array of extraordinary liquidity management measures under UCITS.

If a post-reform European Low Volatility Net Asset Value (LVNAV) or Public Debt Constant Net Asset Value (CNAV) fund’s weekly liquidity falls below 30% and the fund suffers a simultaneous net outflow of above 10%, the ‘board’ must consider applying a fee or gate. If weekly liquidity falls below 10% it must apply either a fee or gate, but retains discretion over which best serves investors.

Of the Fitch-sampled CNAV MMFs boards, all had at least one independent director; however, only a few had boards on which more than half of the directors were independent. On average, funds had 42% independent directors. While this level falls short of a majority, it is higher than the industry-wide average for European UCITS funds (33%) and is marginally higher than the regulatory minimum for US funds (40%).

Women are significantly under-represented on MMF boards. In more than half of our sample, there were no female directors on the board. This low level of diversity is not confined to MMFs, however. Only 11% of directors at European UCITS are women.

The presence of independent directors, combined with effective policies and controls, can help to allay potential agency conflicts. The diversity of a fund’s board can support effective and robust decision-making by adding varied backgrounds and perspectives, helping to ensure that investors’ best interests are served.

The language in the reforms is potentially unclear as to whether the board of the fund or the board of the management company has ultimate responsibility for gate and fee decision-making. In any case, the ‘board’, be it fund or management company, will typically delegate significant responsibility for the management of the fund to the investment advisor.

Fitch sampled 17 umbrella funds governing more than 50 sub-funds. It focused on Ireland- and Luxembourg-domiciled UCITS MMFs and relied on the most recent published versions of the prospectus as of mid-2018. Its sample covered the vast majority of current European CNAV MMFs. It covered 88 fund directors, of whom we consider 36 independent. Fitch defines an independent director as one with no direct or current link to the fund sponsor.

Read the report here

 

Most recent episodes

Future Monetary Policy Path Sets Markets Against Central Banks

Welcome to the latest edition of Liquidity Link Live, your exclusive market analysis provided by Northern Trust Asset Management.

05:19

Podcast - Journeys to Treasury Deep-Dive: Cash Flow Hedge Accounting at JT Group

Listen to this audible case study, which provides a lens over the details of a recent cash flow hedge accounting project undertaking by the JT Group treasury team.

33:38

Podcast - Innovation as an Enabler: Sustaining Global Trade Finance in Uncertain Times

J.P. Morgan's Bayo Osolake, who joins Eleanor Hill (TMI) to discuss how treasurers can facilitate global trade in the currently turbulent macroeconomic environment.

13:07

Relative Normality On Horizon — But Divergent Monetary Policy Pathways Likely

Welcome to the latest edition of Liquidity Link Live, your exclusive market analysis provided by Northern Trust Asset Management.

06:34

Audio TMI - MMF Reform Proposals Threaten LVNAV Viability for European Treasurers

Proposed MMF changes currently being debated at European Commission level endanger the utility of one of the most popular forms of MMF used by corporate investors across the continent.

Audio TMI - Special FX

Two experts from NatWest share the inside track on how treasurers can better manage FX risks by shaking up legacy processes and old-fashioned thinking, improving data coll...

15:27

Audio TMI - Roadmap Towards a First-Class Group Treasury

As the perennial debate continues around the pros and cons of a centralised tre...

12:28

Audio TMI - How Etihad Covered all Three ESG Elements in One Sustainability-Linked Financing

Etihad Airways recently raised US$1.2bn in the first sustainability-linked loan in global aviation with terms that relate to all three areas of ESG.

13:26

Reducing Friction in International Payments: Five Steps for Treasury Teams

What are the steps that treasury teams can take to remove roadblocks in processing international payments? Daniela Eder, Gibran Maqsood, and Karsten Becker (Barclays) to answer this question.

30:31

Keeping the Plates Spinning: the Art of Treasury Project Management

Sandra Shen (Actualize Consulting) joins TMI's Tom Alford to offer professional insight into what defines successful treasury project management. 

18:27