Fitch Ratings: European High-Yield Fund Risk Heightened by Asset-Liability Mismatch

Published 

London: The European high-yield bond fund sector appears to be operating with significant liquidity risk, Fitch Ratings says. Most funds offer daily liquidity to investors despite limited allocations to highly liquid investments. The recent gating of the Woodford Equity Income fund, which had material holdings of unlisted equities, highlights the dangers of offering high liquidity while investing in less-liquid securities, including forced asset sales, material net asset value reductions, gating and potential knock-on effects to the broader financial system.

We analysed Europe’s five largest UCITS high-yield bond funds, with combined assets under management of EUR43 billion at end-March 2019. The funds all offer daily dealing but their holdings of highly liquid securities are limited. We found substantial variation across funds, but on average only 4% of their investments were in cash and only 14% in instruments rated ‘A’ or above, with ‘AAA’ the lowest allocation. Duration averaged three to four years for these funds, depending on the extent to which they included floating-rate securities in their portfolios.

High-yield bond funds are just as likely as government bond funds to offer daily liquidity. To counterbalance the lower liquidity of high-yield securities, they need a diverse investment portfolio to reduce the likelihood of having to divest holdings in distressed names or sectors to pay redemptions. Crucially, they also need to hold appropriate levels of cash or highly liquid investments to help meet spikes in investor withdrawals.

Fund managers face competing demands of liquidity and investment performance. The more cash and highly liquid assets a fund holds for liquidity, the lower the likely yield. This struggle, combined with limited regulatory restrictions, means that liquidity at some funds may not be sufficient to cope with a severe market stress. There are signs that regulators are increasing their focus on liquidity. Tighter regulation leading to a reduced liquidity mismatch would be credit positive for funds and the financial system more broadly.

Funds do not have to offer investors daily liquidity. UCITS regulation provides for funds offering investors various levels of liquidity, including extended settlement periods (up to 10 days) and less frequent dealing (as little as twice a month). However, the asset management sector has opted en masse for daily liquidity, presumably on the basis of investor demand. It may take tighter regulation or a severe market stress to change this approach.

A potential market stress emanating from open-ended bond funds could take multiple paths and affect several sectors. Investment managers could suffer a reduction in assets under management and associated fees, reputational damage or litigation. Banks and non-bank financial institutions could be affected by falling collateral values or by loss of short-term funding from open-ended funds.

Most recent episodes

40th Annual New York Cash Exchange: What Can Treasurers Expect?

Ahead of the 40th annual New York Cash Exchange, two of TMANY’s distinguished board members, David Miller and Timothy T. Hesler, CTP, provide TMI CEO, Robin Page, with a quickfire rundown of what attendees can expect from this year’s conference. Our guests share their aspirations for the event,...

00:00

Expectation-Beating Inflation Prints Ratchet Up Pressure on Monetary Policy

Welcome to the third edition of Liquidity Link Live, your exclusive market analysis provided by Northern Trust Asset Management, one of the world’s largest cash managers. Tune in each month to discover the very latest insights on the UK, Eurozone and US markets. This edition was recorded on the 9th May...

04:48

Making the Sustainable Transition: A Roadmap to ESG in Treasury

Over the last 18 months, Societe Generale has experienced a steady increase in requests from their corporate clients to integrate ESG features in treasury management.  Louis-David Rouyer, Philippe Pougeard, and Emmanuelle Petelle (Societe Generale) provide TMI’s Eleanor Hill with a whistlestop run...

22:24

Lift Off for Fed Rate Rises

Welcome to the latest edition of Liquidity Link Live, your exclusive market analysis provided by Northern Trust Asset Management, one of the world’s largest cash managers. Tune in each month to discover the very latest insights on the UK, Eurozone and US markets. This edition was recorded on the 5th of...

04:58

Treasury in 2022 and Beyond

Industry experts Bob Stark (Kyriba) and Sebastian di Paola (PwC) join TMI’s Editor, Eleanor Hill, to explore the very latest treasury trends – and to discuss how smart treasurers can get ahead of the game by ...

43:21

How BearingPoint Harnessed Data-Driven Forecasting with CashAnalytics and SAP

Listen back to our recent forecasting masterclass, where Group Treasurer Eveline Stam, and Conor Deegan (CashAnalytics) provided TMI’s Eleanor Hill with a comprehensive overview of how consultancy firm BearingPoint achieved company-wide cash forecasting nirvana by combining specialist solutions from...

37:14

The 3 T’s of The Future: Tech, Treasury, and Transformation

Over the past two years, an increasingly dynamic environment has not only accelerated technology development – from quantum computing to blockchain technology, and even the metaverse – but also technology adoption, bridging colleagues and breaking down silos in a remote work world. In this podcast,...

44:02

Monetary Policy Continues to Drive Markets as Ukraine Invasion Weighs on March Meetings

Welcome to the second edition of Liquidity Link Live, your exclusive market analysis provided by Northern Trust Asset Management, one of the world’s largest cash managers. Tune in each month to discover the very latest insights on the UK, Eurozone and US markets. This edition was recorded on the 3rd of...

05:25

Tax Spotlight: How the OECD’s Two-Pillar Solution Impacts Treasury

Aaron Lee and Joseph Lee (DBS Bank) join TMI’s Eleanor Hill to discuss how the OECD’s Two-Pillar Solution aims to address the tax challenges arising from the digitalisation of the economy. Ahead of the 2023 implementation date multinational corporates will have much to consider around these reforms....

24:00

FX Connections: Bringing Transparency to Cross-Currency Payments

Cross-border activity is growing at a remarkable rate, making FX payments a hot topic for treasurers across the globe.  In this TreasuryCast episode, Eleanor Hill asks Daniela Eder and Gibran Maqsood (Barclays Corporate Banking) to provide their key action points around FX payments in 2022. Our guests...

21:00