IMMFA Statement: European Parliament Plenary vote on EU Money Market Fund Regulation

Published 

Today a full plenary session of the European Parliament (EP) agreed its position on Money Market Fund Regulation (MMFR). This report is the Parliament’s response to a legislative proposal put forward by the European Commission (EC) in September 2013.

The agreement by Parliament is another milestone in the EU ‘codecision’ process. Separately, the Council of Ministers (CoM), senior representatives from the 28 EU Member States, is still debating its own position on MMF. Once both the EP and the CoM have agreed their respective positions on the MMFR, the final legislative stage, the Trilogue negotiation with the European Commission, takes place.

It is a positive development that the EP report recognizes that the capital buffer originally suggested by the EC was not a viable proposal for an investment product. It is also worth noting that many of the good market practices which IMMFA funds already adopt voluntarily under the IMMFA Code of Practice, such as credit diversification, prescribed levels of liquidity and a high level of transparency, have been incorporated into the future regulation of money market funds in Europe.

Overall, however, the political compromise that has been reached by Parliament does not augur well for the European capital markets. AUM in European MMF stands at approximately €1 trillion. If implemented, the changes suggested by the EP would have wide-ranging and long-term ramifications for both the constant net asset value (CNAV) and variable net asset value (VNAV) sectors of the money market fund market. The impact on many everyday businesses, local authorities, charities and other MMF investors should not be underestimated. The EP’s proposals reflect the political agenda of various MEPs rather than a serious attempt to reduce systemic risk within the European money markets.

The options presented to the CNAV industry, which makes up >50% of AUM, are severely limited under the Parliament’s draft. The Retail CNAV and EU Public Debt CNAV options are restricted in scope, and under current market conditions together account for less than 10% of the CNAV AUM. The shortcomings of these two options were clearly identified in the impact assessment commissioned by the European Parliamentary Research Service (EPRS) [1] but do not seem to have been taken into account by MEPs.

The proposed LVNAV structure is not an adequate substitute for the CNAV product.

Only a very small proportion of the current CNAV market would be able to transition into this new MMF formulation. Furthermore it is unclear how useful this construct would be to investors. Even then, under a so-called ‘sunset clause’ the authorisation of these funds would lapse five years after the Regulation comes into force. These measures have potential to destabilise the short-term capital markets for years to come.

IMMFA remains confident that through the ongoing negotiation a more feasible solution for the MMF industry will be found – that promotes financial stability whilst preserving efficient short term capital markets in Europe. IMMFA remains committed to working with all parties involved in the regulatory debate and hopes that in the long run an approach which is both practical and effective will prevail.

 

[1] The EPRS Impact Assessment can be found here

Most recent episodes

Future Monetary Policy Path Sets Markets Against Central Banks

Welcome to the latest edition of Liquidity Link Live, your exclusive market analysis provided by Northern Trust Asset Management.

05:19

Podcast - Journeys to Treasury Deep-Dive: Cash Flow Hedge Accounting at JT Group

Listen to this audible case study, which provides a lens over the details of a recent cash flow hedge accounting project undertaking by the JT Group treasury team.

33:38

Podcast - Innovation as an Enabler: Sustaining Global Trade Finance in Uncertain Times

J.P. Morgan's Bayo Osolake, who joins Eleanor Hill (TMI) to discuss how treasurers can facilitate global trade in the currently turbulent macroeconomic environment.

13:07

Relative Normality On Horizon — But Divergent Monetary Policy Pathways Likely

Welcome to the latest edition of Liquidity Link Live, your exclusive market analysis provided by Northern Trust Asset Management.

06:34

Audio TMI - MMF Reform Proposals Threaten LVNAV Viability for European Treasurers

Proposed MMF changes currently being debated at European Commission level endanger the utility of one of the most popular forms of MMF used by corporate investors across the continent.

Audio TMI - Special FX

Two experts from NatWest share the inside track on how treasurers can better manage FX risks by shaking up legacy processes and old-fashioned thinking, improving data coll...

15:27

Audio TMI - Roadmap Towards a First-Class Group Treasury

As the perennial debate continues around the pros and cons of a centralised tre...

12:28

Audio TMI - How Etihad Covered all Three ESG Elements in One Sustainability-Linked Financing

Etihad Airways recently raised US$1.2bn in the first sustainability-linked loan in global aviation with terms that relate to all three areas of ESG.

13:26

Reducing Friction in International Payments: Five Steps for Treasury Teams

What are the steps that treasury teams can take to remove roadblocks in processing international payments? Daniela Eder, Gibran Maqsood, and Karsten Becker (Barclays) to answer this question.

30:31

Keeping the Plates Spinning: the Art of Treasury Project Management

Sandra Shen (Actualize Consulting) joins TMI's Tom Alford to offer professional insight into what defines successful treasury project management. 

18:27